Krugman: Partying Like It's 1929
By SilentPatriot Saturday Mar 22, 2008 9:10amUnregulated, free-market capitalism! Woohoooo!
[W]hat we should be asking is: How did we get here?
The answer, at a fundamental level, is that we’re paying the price for willful amnesia. We chose to forget what happened in the 1930s — and having refused to learn from history, we’re repeating it.
Contrary to popular belief, the stock market crash of 1929 wasn’t the defining moment of the Great Depression. What turned an ordinary recession into a civilization-threatening slump was the wave of bank runs that swept across America in 1930 and 1931.

Login or Register to post comments.
The train wreck of bad debt meets the Saint Paddy's Day Parade of bacchanalian excess at the grade-crossing of destiny.
It doesn't take an economist to understand why its happening.
Voters elected representatives whose only interest is the corporate bottom
line. They elected a commander in chief because they felt that
they could have a beer with him.
With all that's happening across Wall Street, we get video of a president
doing soft shoe at the WH. Or singing parody songs about a traitorous chief of staff.
And on and on and on...
So what does anyone expect from the criminal cabal that stole 2 elections and cheered on ENRON all the way to the end?
GREAT CRIMES DEMAND EVEN GREATER CRIMINALITY!
You ain't seen nothin' yet.
FBush @ 2:
Don't kid yourself - chimpy did not win those 2 elections and the majority of Americans did not want to "have a beer" with an obnoxious AWOL alcoholic/cocaine addict.
Just one of many lies that was used to divert attention from the vote fraud.
I'm sure it's no coincidence that the same regulations that were put in place *after* the '29 crash/depression/economic downturn were the ones being dismantled by the government-is-bad crow. You know, the ones that provided oversight and check measures pertaining to interest rates, banking practices, etc.
I've said it before and I'll say it again. It's time for REregulation, not deregulation. Robber barons and depressions. History repeating itself indeed...
People who put their money in these risky ventures should be the ones who suffer when they go under. That's free-market capitalism. The Fed buying up bad debt to keep these shady operations solvent is socialism.
How to keep that Yukon Denali fueled up enough for the 20 trips to the mall this coming week.
"What we should be asking is: How did we get here?"
Money as debt...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rC720Cl3N-0&feature=related
Bank shmank, I've been considering cashing out my 401-k.
Don't kid yourself - chimpy did not win those 2 elections and the majority of Americans did not want to "have a beer" with an obnoxious AWOL alcoholic/cocaine addict.
The fact that Bush and his gang of thieves got more than 1% of the vote in
'04 is unbelievable. (One percent being the only segment of the population that benefited from
his policies during the first four years.)
I know of too many morons who "liked" him more than Kerry.
No doubt there was fraud in Ohio but if we had an informed population, Bush would have never
gotten in in 2000.
little bear @ 4:
Even I have made the same error but, it was election fraud, not vote fraud. All in all, I got your point.
FBush @ 2:
Once I built a railroad,I made it run,made it race against time
Once I built a railroad;now it's done, Brother can you spare a dime?
Once I built a tower, up to the sun,brick,and rivet,and lime;
Once I built a tower,now it's done,Brother can you spare a dime?
I want to know why we've had this continuous system of various ponzi schemes of the last 20 years?
First the S&L crisis. Money was dumped in fake banks with hopes of making a quick buck.
Then the stock market. All you had to do was dump every bit of your life savings and any equity you had in your house into the stock market and kick back and make 80%. Then the housing mess where you bought and sold your home overnite to make a quick buck.
This all reminds me of the Enron mess. Those guys took money and moved it around to different places and each time the money stopped at a certain place, the investment value went up. They created these shell companies that promised outrageous returns and as along as the money was still moving from one place to another, fake riches were being created on top of the new wealth that was chasing these investments. As long as they were one step ahead of the investigators, they were safe.
I'm sorry if that doesn't make total sense. But to me, it just seems like rich people are able to con us into investing our hard earned dollars into various "investments" that promise great wealth with very little effort and then these "bubbles" are created that pop and the only people that are hurt from the "pop" are the common folks like us because we were told "just invest your money, don't ask questions, it's stupid not to invest, you're losing out, dump all your wealth". So we dump everything we have and they sell us this piece of paper that really is of no value for all our money and they take that money and keep it and the only way you survive is by finding someone more stupid than you to keep selling this piece of paper to.
So any wealth that was earned and created by 50 years of hard work and union wages in the mid 1900s is being taken back by the rich people thru these crazy schemes.
I'm just sick of it. Rich people are the real enemy and they continue to steal and rob us blind and we blame it on the Muslims, the blacks, whoever. People should not be allowed to have more than a basic staple of goods until everyone on this planet is of equal standing. But that will never happen. There's nothing wrong with working and earning and deserving what you get. But that should come after everyone else is taken care of.
The ironic part is there are millions of ways and ideas to solve and fix the problems we face.
I am soooo sick of hearing how 'we' have no money for children's medical care, yet 'we' can bail out a Fortune 50 company that took risks it should have known better than to do.
Privatize the profits, socialize the 'bailout'. Welfare is only for those at the top. Screw everyone else. We're fast approaching a point were more than 50% of the population isn't buying anything that the *don't* need to survive.
we have had the stock market slumping for the last x number of years to anybody watching.
NOW we are seeing the 'bank runs' or similar happening to the big financial orgs.
MSN Money getting religion LMAO
you just know its serious when religion creeps onto serious website sections devoted to Mammon
Nice try in your attempt to paint "free-market" capitalism as the villain.
Milt Friedman proved--literally, with data--that the Federal Reserve caused the Depression by constricting the money supply. Ben Bernanke has admitted Friedman was right.
The problem wasn't the markets. The recession was caused by speculation--and you just can't legislate good judgment no matter how hard you try.
Also, had the GOVERNMENT not reduced the money supply by about a third of its total value after the 1929 crash, then the market would have corrected itself. But once your GOVERNMENT intervened and tried to take action, it caused a panic which resulted in depositors withdrawing their funds, which only made the economic situation worse.
You pretend to know the facts, but you only show that you haven't researched the topic well enough to understand what really happened. And because you have failed to do that, you offer up the same solution that caused the last depression: to wit, you preach government intervention where absolutely none is needed.
The "free-market" is not the cause. Stupid investors buying into hype and not researching their positions are the ones to blame. It happened with buying on margins in the 20s. It happened again in the past 6 years with Time, Newsweek, et al. extolling the gobs of money to be made in the housing market, an industry where liquidity is not easily achivable if it takes a hit.
Instead of letting the people who jumped in head first take their licks and learn their lessons, you instead desire to save them from themselves. This only encourages more of the same behavior in the future. It's called setting a precedent. Government shouldn't be bailing out any bad business choices, whether for the people or for corporations. Like a trapeeze artist working without a net, if you let the market fix itself people have plenty of incentive to regulate their financial affairs much more carefully.
Well, you say that I'm an outlaw,
You say that I'm a thief.
Here's a Christmas dinner
For the families on relief.
Yes, as through this world I've wandered
I've seen lots of funny men;
Some will rob you with a six-gun,
And some with a fountain pen.
And as through your life you travel,
Yes, as through your life you roam,
You won't never see an outlaw
Drive a family from their home.
Lyrics as reprinted in Woody Guthrie, American Folksong, New York, NY, 1961
(reprint of 1947 edition
Ron @ 10:
There was VOTE FRAUD TOO and it and the lying liars in the MSM (with their false 'beer factor" and "energized vote" memes) made it all possible.
christine @ 14:
About 250 billion dollars so far in corporate welfare for failed wall street companies (owned by DC people and their friends).
New Orleans (one of the major regional US cities) got about 10 billion and still half the population is missing / cant go back, and the city still is in ruins in lots of places.
just go look at Google Earth for the masses of blue tarps on rooftops and missing cars and vacant plots damage etc.
Please stop it.
Corporate welfare & protectionism, bank & corporate bailouts, fiat currency, market, rate & currency manipulations, heavy taxation + deficit spending & endless wars have nothing to free-market capitalism. Nothing. Literally.
The whole debate about lightly regulated or completely free-markets versus heavily controlled markets to protect the common good is a valid one. But saying that America's economic woes are the result of unfettered free-market capitalism is like saying that the Iraq war is going badly because Democracy is a failure.
Democracy and capitalism are marketing slogans used and abused by a morally and fiscally bankrupt government that is too stupid to know what they actually mean, and too corrupt to care.
L.A. Confidential @ 1:
Well said.
FBush @ 9:
No doubt there was fraud in Ohio but if we had an informed population, Bush would have never
gotten in in 2000.
Blame the voters all you want - the criminal cabal BEHIND the election with the help of the MSM. Why are you so willing to give them a "free pass"?
Does it make you feel better about your self to blame a faceless mass and pretend to be on the "high ground"?
Bill Maher said it best this past Friday night... to paraphrase, "they" want a free market when things are going good, their personal profits are high, but they want to socialize the losses.
These banks/financial institutions develop "programs" (scams) to increase their own portfolio's, they look to other businesses (mortgage companies) to develop properties for them, sell the mortgages off before they become problematic, and cry when they get hit with the bill. They DO NOT work with the home buyer because they want money, not a solution that will benefit anyone but them. If they have to reduce the mortgage rate they only see a decrease in their profits, not the fact that someone keeps their home, is able to afford all that entails (utilities, food, medical care, GAS!!! and/or transportation). The conservatives talk loud and long about being Christians and the liberals are ruining this country because they support everything evil...... I do seem to remember GREED being listed under the 7 sins.
Deregulation. Plain and simple.
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&add...
And now the banks are begging for government handouts to save them. And the banks are so big, if they fail they swamp other banks and the entire economy. All do to deregulation.
They've privatized gains and socialized losses. You know, because they believe in the sanctity of the free-market.
I am waiting for the Libertarian Pauletts to tell us poor dumb country folk how government regulation makes things worse. How FDR made the 1929 depression much worse with his anti-American socialism big government programs. If we just take all the regulations off of business's back then we would be living in the grand utopia that Capitalism can bring. I am waiting.......
Charles Hess @ 6:
no that's fascism
If you really want to understand how the banking industry is screwing you over, watch Money As Debt.
i got apples... 5 cents each. (One thing thats different I think typewriters had cents signs.)
Dave M. @ 16:
You sound convincing however those same adherents to the static teachings of Friedman and Strauss are screaming for intervention.
Few people here want taxpayers to borrow more from foreign investors to bail out capitol markets.
Dave M. @ 16:
bubble time, just the markets reorganizing themselves, yes its bad for some, most are suffering under just another boom bust election scam cycle.
this time its the middle classes who are ripe for the plucking by vulture capitalists calling in their 'loans'
but you can regulate out the worst of the sharks from eating up small people via deceptive practices.
and put in place financial penalties and prison sentences for the worst of the money crooks out there.
Charles Hess @ 6:
Guess the rules of "free market capitalism" doesn't apply to The Bush Crime Family since we the taxpayers bailed them out to the tune of 1.4 trillion dollars http://members.tripod.com/rationalrevolution0/war/bush_family_and_the_s.htm
but of course the stoopid Retardians got the bust boom cycle wrong, normally you arrange the boom to happen before an election, and the bust after...
Everything is fine! According to the media narcoticized populace.
Some of us learned about this impending event years ago from people with great foresight and understanding of how money works such Robert Kiyosaki and Mike Maloney and tried to tell people on posting board such as this.
All the Bush methane breathing wing-nuts scoffed and pointed to the great boom Bush helped create as if he were the sole reason for it. Now they are eating crow, but at a premium price.
RayC Hussein @ 25:
Its not the Libertarians that hate FDR the most it the Republicans,
Paulians know that FDRs new deal was the right thing for the time, anything else would have caused misery.
Republicans just hate FDR and the idea of helping people period, theirs is the fascist weak to the wall mantra.
VegasRage @ 34:
And they are taking a lot of other people down with them.
Ruthless People @ 31:
Greatest scam-con machine ever created in world History.
little bear @ 22:
Blame the voters all you want - the criminal cabal BEHIND the election with the help of the MSM. Why are you so willing to give them a "free pass"?
Does it make you feel better about your self to blame a faceless mass and pretend to be on the "high ground"?
That "faceless mass" was more than 50% of the population that couldn't separate spin from
the facts about what has been happening to our economy for eight years.
The MSM and its DC Cocktail Circuit is certainly to blame for the pass that Bush has gotten.
But there were just tooooooooooooo many signs that Bush was unfit for the office for the voting public to be given a pass for casting even a SINGLE vote for this buffoon.
I recently heard that the CEOs justify their large salaries and bonuses because they take risks. They are taking risks with our assets with no real repercussions. What a deal. If you have extra money you have choices. You can bury the money in a coffee can in the back yard where it is questionable whether it would be safe or not. It won't give you any return. You can put it in a savings account and it will pay a small amount of interest over the years and considered the safest. Finally, you can invest in the market which pays a higher return with a higher risk, if the market declines. If you takes the higher risk, you should accept it when you lose. The government shouldn't be bailing you out because you were greedy. The ceos shouldn't be getting the huge salaries and bonuses for running a business into the ground,
ep3 @ 12:
"The next bubble: Priming the markets for tomorrow's big crash" by ...
There are a number of plausible candidates for the next bubble, but only a few meet all the criteria. Health care must expand to meet the needs of the aging ...
www.harpers.org/archive/2008/02/0081908
prime mortgages next,
then its onto the BIG ONE the 'derivatives' market, 250 trillion world wide, 8 times the GDP of the planet.
little bear @ 18:
Vote fraud is when the voter tries to vote illegally, election fraud is when the results of the votes are changed illegally.
FBush @ 38:
That "faceless mass" was more than 50% of the population that couldn't separate spin from
the facts about what has been happening to our economy for eight years.
The MSM and its DC Cocktail Circuit is certainly to blame for the pass that Bush has gotten.
But there were just tooooooooooooo many signs that Bush was unfit for the office for the voting public to be given a pass for casting even a SINGLE vote for this buffoon.
Get real - a group of Americans is LOOTING THE FEDERAL TREASURY and getting WEALTHY BEYOND AVERACE!!!!!!! They voted for the chimp - its a rational choice.
Another block sees themselves as "next in line" - they are not making BILLIONS AND BILLIONS of dollars looting the federal treasury, but they want to think it will be their turn next.
Approximately 20 percent of the population is mentally ill.
Factor in racism, illiteracy, and fear as economic opportunities vanish for many groups of Americans.
Pretending to be "above" those that may have voted for dur chimpfuhrer and blaming them for a DEMONSTRABABLY STOLEN ELECTION is arrogance and just as foolish as those you decry.
I personaly don't invest in my companies 401k program. Since the 80's, what underlying value has driven the stock market to it's current value? Me thinks none. Nothing but speculation. The price being paid for stocks cannot continue to go up indefinately. The baby boomers are pretty much the only ones investing in their 401k's. My kids can't. They don't get paid enough. As more and more boomers are let go, retire, die, whatever, where will the money come from to keep values where they are? Once the boomers realize you can't eat stock, you can't swallow it to control blood pressure, it won't heat your home, then what? Returns are so low the only real option is to sell it. To whom? I think inflation plays into this in a huge way also. If prices rise 10% a year, where does that money come from? The company I work for does not give out raises anywhere near that level. So, with everything so damned expensive this will put even MORE preasure on people to NOT put money in their 401K's.
Ron @ 42:
Thanks dr. stupid - so you need to clarify this because you have proof that there was no vote fraud?
Dave M. fuck the "free market" and fuck you. I am sick and tired of this crap. Capitalism will eat everyone and every thing until there is nothing left without serious government regulation. I don't like living in a world where greed is the god that everyone is supposed to idealize. Countries are formed to set the rules for business and the most greedy among us are all ways trying to eliminate or just break those rules. You want no rules on business because you think you will be one of the ruling elite. Greed is not good.
Well, at least Neil Bush will have a job when the whole pinata breaks!
In the meantime, Fbush, the criminals keep getting away with the looting and destroy our constitutional government so that they won't be held accountable (and can keep looting).
And you get to say, "I told you so" - great answer to a complex problem.
takeing my money out of the bank!
The public, fortunately, doesn't understand how bad the situation is. If it did, we might have a real panic on our hands.
tell a lie, it was 500 trillion in 2007
sounds very scientific and sound to me, Emperor's new clothes anybody !
RayC Hussein @ 46:
Thinking the very economic forces that create these economic problems will somehow "solve" them is the definition of insanity - keep give dave the business - the ignorant rantings of that crowd need to be pounced on.
RayC Hussein @ 46:
Wow... Make it personal, why don't ya? Were you one of the people that took that home loan not knowing what you were getting yourself into? Sounds like you just might be...
Why should I, or anyone else here, beforced to pay taxdollars out of our pockets to bail out you or your bank, hmm? And if we don't want to cooperate, what do we get for it? Threats of jailtime. Reeeeeal mature.
And I never said we don't need some rules. We just don't need more of them.
tyree @ 49:
gold is around $1000 oz, in the early 80s it reached an all time high of $850 oz which is aprox $2200 in current inflation adjusted dollars.
it can / could / maybe / will go higher, if things get worse than 1981.
little bear @ 45:
I was only trying to explain the difference to you. If you can't accept a simple explanation, you sir are the one that is stupid.
FBush @ 2:
Hind-sight is 20/20 - too bad your only getting a good look at your own ass!
We were screaming about that problem long before we got to this point...so to bring it up now = too little too late!
Now we need to fight the powers that be so we can stop their corporate greed and their BS "freemarket" dealings.
Unfortunately people voting for the guy they would like to have a beer with is nothing new. We live in a country of apathetic nincompoops who care more about their pocketbook then who is leading our country and our economy. Look it took most people loosing their homes before we started see a real turn out at the polls.
that's why I love when I hear some idiot say "America is the greatest country in the world!" - and I ask "what have we been doing lately that is so great?" - and nobody can give me an answer, they usually just get mad that I would have the balls to ask such a question about America! Sorry people, I am a realist and I do not lie to myself about the kind of people we have in this country. A lot of us a good hard working people who pay attention to politics because we want the world to be a better place...but far more of us couldn't care less!
Dave M. @ 53:
and of course we get down to the nitty gritty of realpolitik of government tax raising,
back to the feudal method of 'give me you money or else' says the nice man with a gun.
of course as anybody with an interest in tax methodology and politics knows, we never left the feudal age.
you refuse to pay your taxes, they jail you, you keep refusing they kill you, quick or slow your choice.
L.A. Confidential @ 50:
They understand what is going on but it is more than denial, it is general helplessness based on sloth.
The G.P. want to believe that the 1/3 of the population that vote in elections are putting sound representatives in office to care for the interest of the 2/3 that would rather drink a beer or smoke a joint than vote for their own interst.
They know but are too busy on their personal path to self destruction to care what the future will be for their kids..........generally speaking of course.
little bear @ 52:
See my link at comment #27.
It's not free-market capitalism that caused this problem, but speculation and government tinkering via the Federal Reserve... Also, look up the Jon Stewart / Alan Greenspan interview from a few months back.
The real insanity is thinking the Fed can fix the problem when its always been the root cause.
Radically Moderate @ 58:
I would be interested to know how many US citizens are disenfranchised from voting due to not being able to register,
lack of suitable ID, 2nd class felon citizen, or scared away from voting stations.
being a British citizen, LPR in the US and soon to be a US citizen,
I find the 'felon' idea and system ridiculous and detestable beyond belief, unworthy of a modern democracy.
The only people in Britain not able to vote are inmates of a prison or people committed to a metal hospital,
outside the walls everybody can vote, including parolees and people on probation.
Krugman is dead wrong!
If the economy needs stimulating; give it to the common people,not the banks.
No money for billionaires!
Must see: Frontline: Secret History of the Credit Card [PBS.org Frontline archives 2004].
Very well said!
ep3 @ 12:
ferrofluid @ 54:
i got a little story to tell thats true! in 64 my brother and i with a few friends climbed the superstition mountains in arizona , looking for the lost dutchmans gold mine, it was mostly just for a lark, after we came down we spotted an old prospector setting in an old rocking chair by a small mine shaft, we walked over to him ,thier was a sighn over the entrence it said BLUE BIRD GOLD MINE! WE GOT INTO A CONVERSATION WITH HIM AND ASKED IS THIER REALLY GOLD IN THAT MINE? HELL YES HE REPLIED , PUZZELED WHY HE WAS JUST SETTING THERE rocking in that chair i asked well why arent you busy digging that gold out , he spit and said we,ll sonny i can get that gold out now and its only 35 dollars an ounce here , or i can get it out and smuggle that gold into mexico and take a chance of getting sent to prison if i get caught, he spit again smiled and said or i can set here on my ass and some day that golds going to be worth 800 dollars an ounce!!we all laughed and thought he.d been setting in the sun to long, well guess he knew something we didnt know!!!!!!!!!like nixon would send henry kissinger to the mid east and encourage the mid east countrys to form an oil cartell so that they could strangle us with thier power to control oil, before kissinger did that a loaf of bread was 25cents and gas was cheap a yr later bread was a dollar , so nixon was the prick who first fucked us good!!!!!!
ferrofluid @ 60:
L.A. Confidential @ 50:
Doesn't matter if the public understands or not really. There is nothing the public can do about it. What causes economic upturns and downturns? Investors and big business. The public is just along for the ride. That has never and will never change. If investors and corporations want to invest cashola, they do. If they want to shrink, they do. Not a damn thing the public can do about it unfortunately.
tyree @ 65:
Great story Tyree. You have had some great adventures in your life.
I've always maintained that the adventure is in the journey rather than the destination.
Of course returning to tell the tail counts for something too.
hi radically , thnx im sure many think im just an old fool whos lived to long , but your right ive seen a lot in my 73 yrs ive seen a depreshion ,seen the hobos rideing the rails watched the destitute pack thier belongings on thier old model tees and head west into the great unknown, guess some died on the way , saw thoes fright trains with thoes hobos change to troop trains and flat cars loaded with tanks and other war eqipment , waved to the soldiers looking from the passenger trains as they made thier way to the war, was one of thoes sailors being waved at by children as they watched us going on to the korean war , god its all history now , i feel so old !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I agree with those who correctly point out that it isn't deregulation but regulation that caused this crisis. The Feds being the most culpable back in the Great Depression and now.
I mean what do you think is going on now. The banks made bad business decisions and they should go bankrupt. But the Feds, a regulatory body, is bailing them out. Of course you will hear the both Democrats and Republicans will talk about protecting the homeowners, but that is code for the lenders/bankers.
People need to start to think for themselves. I challenge anyone to name one regulation that could have prevented this crisis...just one...if deregulation is the culprit.
ferrofluid @ 60:
Theres also a large segment of the population who don't believe in any kind of future, the ones who are waiting for the rapture or the second coming or whatever. In the 1930's it was still possible to have a rational public debate about what to do about the depression. Today I don't think it is possible.