Elitism for Elites
By Barbara OBrien Friday Apr 11, 2008 4:45pmIt always amuses me when upper-class people with power and privilege start screeching about “elitism.” Today all manner of political, media and blogging elites — people with advanced degrees who’ve never been to a tractor pull in their lives — are snorting about elitism because Barack Obama said something that anyone with a real redneck background knows to be true — working-class, small-town whites feel left behind, bitter and frustrated.
Ezra Klein and Marc Ambinder provide good commentary on what Barack Obama said. My remarks today are aimed at the critics who are rushing forward to defend the tender sensibilities of small-town, working class whites that Obama allegedly offended. I say that most of those expressing outrage and defending the "values" of small-town Americans are the real elitists.
Granted, my background is southern Missouri small-town working-class white, rather than Pennsylvania small-town working-class white, and there are subtle cultural distinctions between the two. While I may have kinfolk in half the trailer parks in the Ozarks, I admit that doesn’t qualify me to speak for Pennsylvanians. But over the past forty or so years small-town, working-class white America has been living through the shared experience of diminishing opportunity combined with increasing financial instability.
In community after community, the old factory or mining jobs that sustained the local economy are gone. Forty years ago, young folks left high school, signed on to jobs that paid Union-obtained wages and benefits, and looked forward to all the trappings of American middle-class affluence — homes, new cars, trips to Disney World. Now the bright young people move away to cities, and those who remain in the small towns sustain themselves — barely — by flipping hamburgers or cashiering at Wal-Mart.
The only ones who aren’t bitter and frustrated are those too young or too dim to realize life was much better a couple of generations ago.

Login or Register to post comments.
The real panic here from these assholes is that Barack is stating in very plain language that he's going to address the causes of these problems, not paper them over with patronizing bullshit.
And people are responding.
I know my VA doctor wants me to eat Eliter.
We've definitely been through this before with the 2004 Kerry campaign, where it was primarily liberal media elites that were all to eager to jump on the myth of small town American virtue vs. liberal elitism. I suppose they'll do the same thing this time because it fits so nicely with Obama's inability to BOWL?
And the only other ones who aren’t going to be bitter and frustrated are those too young to remember or are going to be to young to remember what life was like in America Pre Necon takeover Dec 2001.
slippy hussein toad @ 1:
This kind of response?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-bsf2x-aeE
Maha (Barbara) should be the director of all faith based initiatives in the coming Democratic Administration.
Note to Burger Flippers: it is amazing what kinds of things you can create with common kitchen ingredients...especially when your kitchen is the size of a McDonalds!
Note to WalMart Slaves: Pitchforks on Isle 3, torches on Isle 12. Or whatever.
Note to EVERYBODY: eat the rich! These people only have power over us because we LET them. If you are worried about the military suppressing your right to petition for the redress of grievances...most of them are in the same boat AND WILL STAND RIGHT THERE BESIDE YOU!
2008 is the last gasp of HOPE for a better future, and justice for past crimes, this country has. If that hope dies...a population without hope is a population that starts looking for payback. I fervently wish that we can see a GOOD president, and PROGRESSIVE government, starting in 2009.
But if it gets stolen AGAIN...I know what will happen. YOU ALL know what will happen, INCLUDING YOU AGENT SMITH OF THE NSA READING THIS! IF YOUR FASCIST ASS WANTS TO PREVENT VIOLENCE BREAKING OUT NATION-WIDE IN 2009, YOU CAN START BY ARRESTING THOSE ENEMIES OF THE CONSTITUTION IN THE BU$CO REGIME, STARTING FROM THE TOP! OR DOES YOUR OATH TO PROTECT AND DEFEND "THAT DAMN PIECE OF PAPER" MEAN NOTHING TO YOU!
slippy hussein toad @ 1:
To what? What's his plan for rural America? Right now, all I hear are gaseous emissions from all sides.
As far as todays emerging youth there are two types.
Wilkes Barre P.A. The city remains in poor shape, with those bad newer buildings (now aging badly), and the "missing teeth" of more recent demolitions, and a sagging population base. But I liked the young professionals I met there who are working to revive this very damaged place. They were intelligent, and cheerful despite the difficulty of their task. They clearly loved their town. They were free to move elsewhere, had even been to college elsewhere, but had returned to their old city in the valley to make a stand. And they had worked tirelessly to actually get a few good new things built.
The Other Type. Lets build more buildings that are little more than packing crates with bars and bandstands, while the side streets are adorned with rows of port-a-johns reeking in the impressive heat while hosting drinking contests on Sixth Street every weekend night for visiting motorists.
While I may have kinfolk in half the trailer parks in the Ozarks. Your quote is Hill-arious, one has to be from the area to appreciate the subtle inference.
Raised in rural Indiana, put myself through college and then some, parents never had money, worked growing up on farms and blue collar jobs. I'd say Obama got it exactly right, and that he truly does empathize with the people he's talking about and understand what it means too be left out and left behind. Clinton's and McCain's criticisms don't ring true, being more than anything, patronizing. I think Hillary in her heart does care, but she's so desperate that she's saying these things just to score points, which demeans her. I hate to see her stooping and trash talking. It's pathetic. McCain's concerns are ridiculous, a joke.
it isn't just the "bitter" comment that was insulting. it's then implying that the poor bitter backwater rubes could only possibly support pro-gun, anti-gay, anti-immigrant positions because their economic situation had so drastically declined. not sure what the two things have to do with each other at all, and apparently neither does Prince Barack.
The GOP has duped their supporters into thinking the polo pony Republicans are looking after the best interests of the Wal-Mart Republicans.
You can fool some of the people all of the time. Conservatives are those people.
I'm tired of the other campaigns and the media making a major league deal over a piddly comment. The leaders of our nation sat in the White House discussing torture methods, our economy is a mess, we're in a never-ending war, the whole world hates us, it takes two plus incomes to live a decent life and our kids aren't graduating from high school. Why on earth would anyone be bitter about that?
Great point John and I wish more of these small town people who realize what you have said that within such communities, there does exist an elitism of sorts that does not function in the modern american let alone the modern world.
What about those of us with advanced degrees who have been to tractor pulls and demolition derbies? Those county fairs left quite an impression on me while growing up in the 70s.
I'm not the least bit offended by Obama. But what do I know?
I'm scared. Supreme court or not, I just don't think I can bring myself to vote for Hillary, if by some slight of hand she gets nominated. Seeing and hearing her jump on Barack, calling him an elitist makes me want to literally puke my guts out. The two faced creeps like both Clintons and McCain are just about too much to bear. How much was it that the Clintons made last year? How much is Cindy McCain worth? Please oh please gimme a break!
And please tell me that there aren't a very large number of embittered Americans struggling to survive.
lolo @ 8:
Tell that to the 1.2 million individual donors to Obama.
If McCain had made this remark he would have been lauded to the skies.
Snobama 08! @ 12:
I guess you didn't even listen to what he was saying. Your concern has been duly noted.
pfeld @ 17:
Look fear straight in eye and you will cease to be afraid of it. Don't get stuck in it's grip, do something to advance.
Even though I lived through the Sixties (college and the Army), I've never been a huge fan of protest songs—until I heard James (son of Larry) McMurtry's "We can't make it here anymore."
He sums up the devastation visited on working people in this country more evocatively and passionately than anything else I've ever heard.
Download it (iTunes or eMusic) and hear for yourself.
pfeld @ 17:
Hillary still is better than McCain in every possible way, so unless you want Mr.-100-Years McPapen in office in January 2009, you'd probably have to vote Hillary.
On the OP: Couldn't have said it better myself! Bravo, Senator Obama!
Who has been more elite over the years the the whole right wing? Who have been more exclusionary and who wants to exclude people from even the basic right of voting?
This is off topic. I just check redstate (scary place I tell you), because I want to know the way they think (stupid, if not psychotic). Anyway, those of you who still doubt Senator Obama would not win in the generals should check how they feel about him (if you don't want to give them hits, i'll elaborate): Those wingnuts have 6 out 10 entries (including the more recent 4) about Sen. Obama, and everytime I check them most of their entries are about him. They fear him. They know he would beat the crap out of them.
Oh man, what an opportunity! Someone should start cranking out bumper stickers as fast as they can that simply say:
EMBITTERED AMERICAN
Let's hope that Obama keeps telling it as it is and doesn't start to fold under the pressure. If he can stay true to his principles, and if the American people are smart enough to see through the B.S. that will be flung at him, y'all might just have a brighter future in store.
teedawg @ 11:
I don't even think this is about what he said, but to whom he said it and the circumstances....in a closed fundraiser with a bunch of fat cats waiting to take their money. It's obvious that this will be another free pass for Obama, he can be inartful and misspeak and never be held to task....must be nice!
Idols are manufactured. You could take a moonshine hillbilly who dropped out of school in the 4th grade and with enough time, money, coaching, and promotion turn him into a sophisticated gentlemen fit for public consumption.
Technically we're all full of bullshit in the bigger scheme of things.
Let me see of I got this straight, people are upset because Obama said that poor people are unhappy with being poor?
hood @ 25:
Not much of an indicator. Those people are haters. They're gonna hate all over whoever they think is the Dem frontrunner.
Please someone explain to me why obama is supposed to be an expert on everything and is supposed to know how every body feels about anything and everything.
Since he only stayed with his Kenyan grandmother for a few years, and the rest of his life he lived with people of means how does he know about the people who are the have nots.
His mother left him with affluent grandparents after his father deserted them. Then when she married someone else...he was wealthy. I guess since obama is supposed to be the second coming of the Good Lord we must expect him to be the all knowing about everything.
Old School Patriot @ 7:
Indeed, the soldier is just another exploited worker, it is the awakening of their consciousness that turns a crisis into a revolution. So wake up Soldier! you are being used, those orders are illegal orders and you have no obligation to follow them.
Of course Obama is an elitist. After his "weird" behavior in Indiana the other day, can there still be any doubt? For those of you who don't watch "Hardball" Obama actually went into a diner and asked for ORANGE JUICE! This behavior was so bizarre that it led to a detailed discussion by Chris Matthews and David Schuster culminating in Matthews' asking Senator Casey just what is "wrong" with Obama. This campaign season gets more demented every day.
Marge @ 32:
Let's see. There are the years he spent being a community organizer in Chicago and being a professor takes some kind of knowledge. Outside of bieng first lady and a politician what has Hillary done again?
slippy hussein toad @ 1:
How is he going to solve these problems?
Diane @ 360:
By trying?
That would be a nice begining, don't you think?
RLF @ 103:
I don't think he's an empty suit, but like you, I sometimes feel he is promising 2 chickens for every pot. Factories have closed in many towns, jobs are gone, people are having a hard time and *do* feel like the government doesn't care about them. However, these factories/mines *are* a thing of the past and they are NOT going to come back. Technology has been a factor as well as the outsourcing of jobs to China (more than to Mexico, in my opinion).
How is Obama going to change or re-juvenate the situation any more expertly than anyone else? It's impossible to bring back the past. How is he going to create new jobs for these people? Is he going to make sure they all get trained for new jobs? A former steel worker is going to be trained to be.... what? Forklift operators are going to be trained to be....nurse's aids? It's one thing to say you understand why people are angry and bitter and another thing entirely to do something that will change their economic situation which Obama seems to imply is behind the anger. If anyone knows where Obama has specifically laid out his plans, let me know, please.
xoites defends Constitution @ 356:
If you think a vile sermon given when bodies were still burning at th WTC was worth applauding. Then you are pathetic buddy.
Not perfect but fixable even with scum like Wright.
xoites [EMBITTERED AMERICAN] defends Constitution @ 361:
Our government has been run the last seven years by people whose ideology is that government doesn't work. They've done their absolute best not to disprove that ideology. I think we may have forgotten what a government that "tries" is.
RLF @ 363:
and I'm a big size man. Little brain
RLF @ 363:
Vile? and i think you have your dates mixed up.
Anyway if you want to talk about vile let's get down to it.
Wright said God Damn America, right?
To you this is vile, to me this is polite.
What has America done?
Read The People's History of the United States by Howard Zinn and get back to me.
You REALLY need to expand your data base.
RLF @ 363:
The conservatives want presidents like George W. Bush and Mitt Romney.
But not Obama because he's an elitist.
His dad was a third world goat herder and now you want us to believe he's an elitist.
The conservatives love religious figures like Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell.
But not Rev. Wright because he preaches hate.
When the bodies were still burning, Pat and Jerry were on NATIONAL TELEVISION, happy as clams that God was punishing America because of feminism and homosexuality.
Brealistic @ 280:
Lessee, a troll bagging on Obama audiences when their BFF Preznit hasn't had a single event that has not been held at (a) a neo-nut Think tank; (b) a Military base (you know where they HAVE To clap for the COC or get a year's KP; or (c) a hand picked audience of flat-earthed, Old Testament thumpin', tax-hatin' recidivist history flunkie kool aid snorters? Give me a F**king break. Have you no sense of shame, sir or madam? At the very least you have a fatally defective short term memory prob.
joeedugan @ 367:
Don't get wrong their scum with longer resumes.
lost_nacf_gop @ 368:
Not to mention you have to sign an Oath of Loyalty to get in.
xoites [EMBITTERED AMERICAN] defends Constitution @ 366:
Keep using that self hate tact you might pick up the "I hate America" vote. All 5 of them.
THINK!!!!
"Don’t get wrong their scum with longer resumes"
Anybody got Breality to English dictionary?
geneHUSSEIN214 @ 153:
Odd that my comment would be deleted but the flame response remains. gen has to make outrageous smears about anyone who makes a comment that seems like anything less than being in 100% support of his candidate and in doing so, proved the point I was making.
It's not Hillary who is tearing the party apart: it's people like gene and his other fellow Obama supporters.
RLF @ 371:
If you do not hate the atrocities America has committed you don't think at all. But i figured that out about you hours ago.
RLF @ 371:
Did you hear what Rev. Wright actually said in full context? Does this sound like "I hate America" to you?
Nomi @ 373:
Your comment made no sense. I responded to it as wel. Why did you not quote me?
Afraid?
Nicole Belle @ 375:
Nicole, i respect you a lot, but i thought it was my job to talk to the brick walls around here. :)
xoites [EMBITTERED AMERICAN] defends Constitution @ 374:
We'll get a truckload of real, substanced candidates for Federal office again . . .once we decide to stop treating the effing process like the MIss America Pageant. Wolf-F**king Blitzer, meet Bert Parks.
Obama said nothing that was wrong or inaccurate. Grow up toadies. Smell your own farts for a change.
lost_nacf_gop @ 378:
I beg to differ. Obama spat in the face of THE BIG LIE.
The BIG LIE is (among other things), "Isn't it great that Americans have the freedom to work three jobs?[to make ends meet]"
I work in a factory in Indiana that is on its death bed. By this coming fall all of the machines will be in Montery, Mexico. Every day I get up and go to work bitter, and everyone else that I work with is bitter as well. Obama's comments were dead on. Why this story has any legs is beyond me. People everywhere in this country ARE bitter and they should be. For too long now OUR country has been taken from us. We feel helpless and frustrated and bitter about the things that we see going on every day in Washington. I just hope the day comes when we decide that we've had enough of it.
xoites [EMBITTERED AMERICAN] defends Constitution @ 377:
My bad. :) Talk away.
Pete @ 381:
I am sorry for the loss of your job, Pete. What are you going to do?
Actually the LIE was "uniquely American . . . workin' three jobs. Uttered by a guy whose never worked ONE in his whole miserable adult life.
Nicole Belle @ 382:
I was just teasing, you can pounce on the trolls any time you like. :)
getalife @ 43:
You have completely lost touch with reality now.
>Clinton praises the voters and will fight for
>them to give them hope for their future.
Wow. How cool for her. Have you read the comments here, today, on this thread? Have you not read a dozen comments from people from small towns in Pennsyvania (claim to be I should say, just for accuracy - I have no reason to doubt them, do you?) and testified that Obama hit the nail on the head. People are bitter and angry.
And here you come along all smug N shit and tell us Hillary respects the voters and praises them, to give them hope. You are an idiot. I am just SO fed up with crap like this already. Get with the program already. You are supposed to be a Democrat - how can you live with yourself knowing you may be trashing OUR candidate? I can only assume you have no soul.
lost_nacf_gop @ 384:
You are correct. I remember now. It is really hard for me to watch or listen to thar man.
xoites [EMBITTERED AMERICAN] defends Constitution @ 374:
Take a good look at world history All "civilized" nations are built on atrocities. I think we should stop committing them. But unfortunately it will take a shift in human nature and that usually takes many years.
Since you like using insults like your hero Wright you might understand that.
No one like yourself changes anything. Non-entities spouting hatred never do.
I thought Obama treatise was to embrace to bring together. I guess you are truly representative of him.
I ask anyone who reads this to read the whole thread and discover the heart of a true Obama follower.
Pete @ 381:
Pete, the day is when you want it to be. Watch the candidates, and you'll be able to tell which ones have no clue what you're going through, and are unable to care about it. There's two of 'em in the race.
RLF @ 388:
You just do not and refuse to "get it!"
This is my country and your country. It is the very first country on the planet where what it does is both my and your responsibility. It is not suppossed to be a monarchy where we can throw up our hands and say, "The King did it!"
What this country does is ALWAYS in our name.
Fuck what other countries do!
Take resposnsibility and stop deflecting blame on everyone else!
Grow the Fuck Up!
"I ask anyone who reads this to read the whole thread and discover the heart of a true Obama follower."
Well i support him. I follow noone. I think that is all you are capable of.
Yes, please feel free to read this thread, all criticizm of what i say is welcome.
I'm unemployed in Flint Michigan so tell ME that I'm not bitter and frustrated! Now maybe I'm not in the least interested in god or guns but that's really just a minor kvetch and not at all some horrible slight to us poor white mid-westerners. This country has gone to hell, I can't even get a job working for the local great Satan (Wal-Mart), and I AM MAD AS HELL, AND I'M NOT GOING TO TAKE IT ANY LONGER!
xoites [EMBITTERED AMERICAN] defends Constitution @ 390:
WOW you total lack of history is astounding. A third entity called America did not commit atrocities. It was you and me ,our parents ,and their parents before. Atrocities are committed by people not kings, emperors, and dictators. Every atrocity ever committed was by a person, not an entity. The indians were slaughtered for their land by us not the government. If the govt. did anything it was by our acquiescence not their lead. And so forth throughout history.
Unlike you I refuse to use derogatory language. But seriously wake up!
xoites [EMBITTERED AMERICAN] defends Constitution @ 391:
Hey man get some more sleep, your spelling is way off.
Eric Hussein Paulsen @ 392:
Pete @ 381:
Folks like you scare the shit out of the real ellite. If you get organized people like Hillary could lose their summer homes in the Hamptons. Obama scares them just for pointing out your plight and taking your side.
Your side is my side and always has been.
Snobama 08! @ 12:
Anyone born around the rust belt area will tell you this much is true. People ARE angry AND bitter. I know, I was just up in that area and the locals at the bars are ready to organize, and take back what the bushites have stolen from our country.
OH...........BTW, you are a POS TROLL.......
I think the people who are upset, are Hillary Clinton and John McCain that this inner city black boy is beating their butts and knows something about the frustrations that he is talking about. What does someone whose made 109 million dollars in the last 7 years know about what the laid off workers in Pennsylvania think or feel.
The "elitist" term is code word for smart, and it was used as an attack against Bill Clinton in the 1990's. He was also called a "policy wonk" for knowing too much about government. I find it ironic that the Clinton's throw these same accusations at a black man who grew up in the inner city and worked his way to where he is today.
If there is one thing that we can't have in this country is a smart president who will bring people together!!!! So we will call him elitist when he calls a spade a spade.
I live in the south and I can tell you personally that people who have no real power cling to God and guns to try to get through this life. Obama speaks the truth and it is too painful for the two real "ELITISTS" running against him. Obama scares them to death.
The orange juice scandal came out the same day that George Bush admitted that he knew about the secret meetings on torture going on in his cabinets and he approved of them. Guess which story got the most media.
"GEORGE BUSH KNEW ABOUT TORTURE MEETINGS, BUT LOOK OVER THERE, OBAMA ORDERED ORANGE JUICE."