McCain blames Minnesota bridge collapse on earmarks
By Steve Benen Thursday May 01, 2008 5:00pm
Joe Klein recently predicted that John McCain would avoid a cheap and pathetic style of campaigning. McCain, Klein said, “sees the tawdry ceremonies of politics — the spin and hucksterism — as unworthy.” If he doesn’t, “McCain will have to live with the knowledge that in the most important business of his life, he chose expediency over honor.”
At this point, if McCain is experiencing any kind of internal dilemma, I’m pretty sure hucksterism is winning.
Republican John McCain said Wednesday that the bridge collapse in Minnesota that killed 13 people last year would not have happened if Congress had not wasted so much money on pork-barrel spending.
Federal investigators cite undersize steel plates as the “critical factor” in the collapse of the bridge. Heavy loads of construction materials on the bridge also contributed to the disaster that injured 145 people on Aug. 1, according to preliminary findings by the National Transportation Safety Board.
“The bridge in Minneapolis didn’t collapse because there wasn’t enough money,” McCain told reporters while campaigning in Pennsylvania. “The bridge in Minneapolis collapsed because so much money was spent on wasteful, unnecessary pork-barrel projects.”
This is so cheap and crass, I’m almost surprised his remarks didn’t spark some kind of controversy. If McCain is willing to aim this low in the spring, what can we expect from in the fall?
This one was so shameless, even some of his supporters in Minnesota are keeping their distance.


Login or Register to post comments.
I’m First. I would like to thank my family and friends for making this all possible. I could not have done it without them. Also I would like to thank John Amato for opening up his website to this lonely peon. Thank you John. Also I wish this god damn election was over so we could move onto the trials to throw the Republicans who put us in this position. God bless you all.
McCain is an idiot. If we can't beat him, we have serious problems.
McCain is not a "natural born citizen" having been born in the Panama Canal Zone in 1936.
If elected he may not be able to take the oath of office.
Just curious which of the earmarks that McCain got for Arizona caused this bridge to collapse. I'm just sayin'.
Well, since reality doesn't seem to factor into the proceedings, I shall blame it on invisible pterodactyls flapping their wings too hard.
What about the Trillions were wasting in Iraq Senator McCain? What about the Republican policies of the last several years. Do you want to know why that bridge collapsed Senator Mccain? Because Rebugs don't give a crap about people like us. We are lowly peons to big-shots like you.
McCain does not know if he is coming or going. Do you remember how they called Kerry a flip flopper over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over.
McWideoftheMarkOpportunist.
How many moronic flubs and gaffs has McSame delivered already? A lot, but they're buried on the back page as Obama and Billary continue to pound on each other.
McSame is coasting along...with no one questioning his moronic comments.
Captain Bitter Elitist Hussein Kangaroo @ 7:
Remember those silly idiots at the 04 GOP convention grinning like children on a schoolyard, flip-flopping their hands and chanting, "flip-flop"? Made me sick on so many levels.
And those purple band-aids...!!!! Re-UGH-licans....
McDoesntSeetheBigPicture
What a simple and small-minded little man like Chimpy this stupid old turd is.........
I used to respect McCain, particularly after Bush did the smear job on him in 2000. But he has flipped on EVERYTHING! Tax cuts, religious views, etc. McCain IS Bush, his policies will be the same. Ask yourself,"Do we really want another Bush in the White House."
P.D. @ 6:
And this asshole wantd to attack Iran and stay in Iraq for another hundred years and they spend a shitload of money building schools and roads in Iraq as I type. This mental midget is blaming earmarks? I’m blaming Bush and the stupid fucking war. I’m blaming tax cuts to the richest sons of bitches in the world. I’m blaming tax cuts for the biggest corporations in the world. This mental midget wants to make these tax cuts permanent. He also wants to have a gas tax “holiday” this summer. This gas tax pays for these bridges that are falling down. I am so pissed off right now I could spit.
It really makes me sick when political hacks use the deaths of innocent people as stage props in a political campaign.
Does pork-barrel spending sometimes go to useless or unnecessary things? Yes.
But to say a lack of money for the repair of bridges and roads to prevent such things from happening is strictly because of pork-barrel spending is nonsense.
Apparently the senator hasn't looked at the Iraq bill recently, or at all, and he supports the continuation of the war.
Plus, he is in favor of unnecessary tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans. Gee, wouldn't that lost revenue be useful for something, like, fixing roads and bridges?
Bonkers Hussein @ 10:
Oh my god. The DNC has got to get a copy of the video and put into an anti McCain ad. Now that would be good. Let fire off an email to Howard Dean. I'll give you credit.
I've got a sinking feeling in my stomach that somehow the election will be stolen AGAIN. That's of course assuming that the Bush gang let an election go on. There's so much that could change between now and November. Why George might get a hangnail and decide to declare martial law. He of course gave himself the power to do that for just about any reason at all. Be afraid people, not of the foreign terrorists, be afraid of the ones in Washington.
McCain will get a free pass all the way until November because attacking him can be considered a form of "elder-abuse" and abuse of the the elderly (even verbally) is a crime in most states.
Captain Bitter, you are right! If only we would impeach this president, the world might have more respect for us, but no. There Bush is, still in the White House with scandals coming out everyday. Depressing no? The war my very well finish this country. And our leaders are spineless. History will not be kind.
If I'm not mistaken, isn't freeway/bridge infrastructure at least partially funded by the program he intends to personally defund to give everyone a "Gas Tax Holiday"?
Nathan @ 3:
Oh, come on. He was born on a US military base.
P.D. @ 19:
Don't you remember what Bush said about history? It doesn't matter because "We'll all be dead."
Dave, I too, fear the election will be rigged. To this day I cant believe Kerry lost. I don't think I can deal with another heartache.
LOL Rico, Did he actually say that! I can just see it. God, what a dope!
Rico @ 18:
No, not November - I think the dem candidate can justifiably rip McHole a new one during debates.
JoeyD @ 4:
Yeah, really! :)
pork barrel –noun Informal. a government appropriation, bill, or policy that supplies funds for local improvements designed to ingratiate legislators with their constituents.
McCain's fallacy.
Pork Barrel spending keeps bridges from being built or repaired; event hough , Pork Barrel spending is defined as money spent on local improvements such as repairing or building new bridges.
Your right Blue Lensman, Hillary or Obama will mop the floor with him. No softball questions, no light banter. They should go right for the jugular.
CNN just put the McCain clip up about oil and the war. McCain spun it into nonsense on the plane after the McFuckup.
You mean porkbarrel like Iraq McCain?
Captain Bitter Elitist Hussein Kangaroo @ 29:
*According to Dana Gash. The CNN PR person for McCant on his campaign.
Orangutan. @ 2:
If we can't beat him, we need to start a mass migration to somewhere else.
ConcernedCanuck @ 30:
Iraq is not Pork Barrel Spending. Iraq is a full fledge looting of the Royal Treasury.
P.D. @ 28:
Do Democrats ever go for the jugular? I'll believe it when I see it.
Why isn't the oil statement all over the airwaves? A brief mention here, a breif mention there, and that is about it. Even on the web-sites, nothing. CBS, MSNBC, CNN. But they certainly played the Wright bullshit over and over again. WTF?
Earmarks were also behind 911!
Billy Bob, Where would we migrate? Our reputation is so bad, people are claiming they are Canadian. And that my friends, is so incredibly sad.
P.D. @ 35:
CNN just played it again. Wolfie is discussing it with Jack and the other panelists.
From Steve Benen's last link:
Did McCain just blame the drowning of New Orleans on pork-barrel spending too? [His reference to "pork-barrel spending" being intended for Democrats, who didn't take over Congress until 2007.]
Captain Bitter Elitist Hussein Kangaroo @ 38:
They are calling McShame out on it. David Gergan said the McCain didn't mispeak like McCain's apologists said.
Captain Bitter, That's it? If Hillary or Obama said it, they would hound them to death. Oh, you got to love MSM!
Actually if you want to make our freeways and bridges stronger and more confident, we need to make the tax cuts permanent.
At least Gregory isn't as bad as Wolfie. But notice how quickly they move on? Jeez! If it was a Democrat, Faux News would be sceaming bloody murder.
Damien @ 42:
Making the tax cuts permanent and giving the telecoms immunity for spying illegally on Americans will make the world safe for democracy AND make our bridges safer. [snark]
There's a much more direct link between the bridge collapse and "crony capitalism." The NTSB released some pictures of failing portions of the bridge that were taken as part of an inspection in 2003. A competent firm would have immediately recognized a serious danger. The firm that did that inspection (and subsequent ones) was URS Group, a company run by Diane Feinstein's husband and full of lots of big Republican donors.
Competency isn't the criteria on which these contracts were decided. This is what happens when you let Senators sleep with lobbyists.
By the way, URS Group is also the folks who staged the mock hurricane practice in New Orleans called Hurricane Pam - IN 2004! If these people had their thumbs out of their buts they could have put together a recommendation list before Katrina, at least.
Public financing of elections would go a long way towards fxing this bullshit.
Leslie [Hussein] @ 39:
Before you jump the gun, he might be regarding to the canals that were built through the wetlands that are now dissapppearing. That project dates back to the '60's or '70's- when Dems controlled the Congress.
Not that I'm defending the guy, because, if I'm right, the guy is trying to blame today's Dems for the pork barrel spending of 40 years ago. Some evidence, huh?
Loonie @ 5:
Someone in China stepped on a butterfly.
WHERE IS THE PORK..... john THE REPUBLICAN mccain CAUSED THE BRIDGE TO FALL....
here is why
McCain’s claim is false. In 2006, the senator teamed up with fellow Arizona senator Jon Kyl (R) to funnel $10 million toward the University of Arizona for an academic center named after the late Supreme Court Justice William Rehnquist. Even Arizona lawmaker, Rep. Jeff Flake (R), said he was planning to “lean against the measure.” The National Taxpayers Union, another traditional McCain ally, questioned why the senator was making federal taxpayers foot the bill for the center.
In 2003, McCain also slipped $14.3 million into a defense appropriations bill to
create a buffer zone around Luke Air Force Base in Arizona. As Roll Call reported in 2003, this project violated McCain’s own anti-pork rhetoric:
The only problem is the project to acquire more land near the base was not requested by President Bush or fully authorized by the Senate Armed Services Committee - two of McCain’s criteria for identifying so-called ‘pork.
Sen. Ted Stevens (R-AK), a notorious porker, was overjoyed that McCain had joined his side. “One man’s pork is another man’s alternate white meat,” said Stevens. “If he asked for it, we put it in.”
P.D. @ 43:
I'm beginning to think that the MSM id just giving people what they want. I mean middle America people. Middle America is so stupid and believe only what they want. There was the guy on 60 Minutes when they did an Obama or Hillary piece and this redneck was saying that Obama was a Mooooslum. He had heard. The 60 Minutes guy told him he was wrong but the guy obviously didn't want to believe him. He probably got the information from the email thing or from one of his drinking buddies who got the email. It just showed me people get what they really want out of anything. Of course the people here know better. We know what is going on but middle America don't really give a shit. They hear what they want to.
The republicans were in charge of spending since 94 and did nothing to fix roads and bridges. Just another reason they lost the 06 elections and will lose in 08 also.
So let me get this straight. McCain makes verbal blunders daily, and Hillary vows to "obliterate" Iran and isn't even questioned about it, while at the same time McCain and Clinton both pander to the American people with a "gas tax holiday" that will only make more bridges fall, and put more money in the pockets of the oil companies, yet the MSM is still pounding to death talk about Rev. Wright and whether or not Obama has testicles. Where's my passport?
Captain Bitter Elitist Hussein Kangaroo @ 31:
Oh, you mean Ms. Blinky? That reporter with the big soft boiled egg eyes makes me crazy every time she is on the air. I have no idea how good or bad, how biased or unbiased she may be...all I do is obsessively count the times she blinks those eyes. Sometimes over a hundred in a single report. Just watch next time...and count.
I Like Pie @ 14:
As the 2008 RNC convention is in Minneapolis later this year, and thus only a few miles away from the collapsed bridge,
I hope McInsane+RNC is going to have zome serious security if they carry on saying garbage like this.
They are going to need it.
Captain Bitter, I think the South never got over losing the Civil War. They would prefer to let our country suffer because of their religious and bigoted beliefs. They refuse to listen to reason. And cling to the Bible to look down on the so-called "progressives and liberals". My mother, unfortunatly, is one of them.
OK - this kind of spending is never going away. At the risk of being "real", the representatives that get re-elected are the ones who can bring federal money into their district. That is, in many real ways, why they are there in the first place.
Money that YOU can bring home "pays for critical local infrastructure", while money that anyone ELSE brings home is "Pork Barrel" spending.
But anyway... at the risk of repeating my #20 comment - isn't ANYONE going to notice the fact that he's SIMULTANEOUSLY lamenting unrelated "buzzword" factors that had nothing to do with this bridge collapse while proposing a Gas Holiday whose entire funding will be stolen from the very program that specifically is responsible for maintaining this kind of infrastructure?
Rico @ 51:
Yup! That pretty well sums it up. Course, I could add that the Taliban is retaking Afghanistan, al Qaeda is still a threat, Muqtada al-Sadr is gaining in Iraq, it was the bloodiest month for US troops in Iraq, unemployment is way up, mortgage defaults are way up...but what's most important??? I mean really...what's really important...
listening for the 20-millionth time to what some guy who isn't running for president said.
MSM=White noise.
P.D. @ 54:
Yes, you are... er... correct (I hate the word "right" these days). It still makes me bitter. They probably cling to their guns as well.
Andy K Jong Il @ 46:
To clarify, I think he's referring to the MRGO project, funded in '56 and completed in '65. Definitely Dems, but still- 52 years ago!
Andy K Jong Il @ 46:
The next line in that story is funny:
The MRGO (which is what McCain should have been referring to) was finished in 1965. Maintenance of it is part of the Corps of Engineers budget. Its not an earmark, and I don't think it ever was. The author was trying to fill in the blanks for McCain, and couldn't help but fudge the facts.
Old Billy Hussein @ 60:
I'm happy to read that! Thank You! :D
Earmarks could have saved that bridge!!!!
From Google News, both stories on the same page at the same time:
$38M deal reached for Minn. bridge collapse victims
Clinton seeks gas tax vote, Obama calls it 'shell' game
Gas Taxes should have been raised a lot several years ago, to repair failing infrastructure, to finance Mass Transit and to discourage the use of gasoline.
Now - in crisis over infrastructure & high gas prices - in any way cutting or suspending those taxes would be criminal, and have very little benefit to the average American .. perhaps $30.
MountainMan23 @ 63:
That's $30 for the entire summer.
Old Billy Hussein @ 45:
FYI The bridge not only failed the inspection; but, received one of the lowest safety scores in the nation.
FYI The Hurricane Pam exercise was cancelled, half way through, because of budget cut backs initiated by President Bush.
The bridge collapse is mostly the fault of the failed policies of Repulican governor of Minnesota Tim Pawlenty WHO IS A STRONG MCCAIN SUPPORTER.
Damien @ 20:
We have a winner! Give the poster another $600 loan from China!!
We quit rebuilding our infrastructure when Reagan took office in the 80's -- just one more way to drown government in the bathtub so that private investors can step up and own every bit of this country so we can pay tolls on the roads we drive on, the food we eat, the air we breathe, and the water we drink.
If no one is making a profit on it, then what good is it? The only problem is, the only people that have the money to buy the infrastructures live in China, Dubai, and Saudia Arabia now...
And they already own our ports...
What ever happened to "providing for the common good"?
Leslie [Hussein] @ 64:
So, $600 "rebate" (loan on next year's taxes) and $30 for gas... I think that my vote is worth a H*LL of alot more than that.
Yeah, right Johnny asshole. It has nothing to do with the fact that our entire national infrastructure is collapsing, because you GOP psychopath millionaires don't pay taxes anymore (along with your corporate gazillionaires).
You cretin's have eliminated every last penny for the common good, so that multimillionaires can have $200 million dollars of disposable income to play with a year, instead of $150 million. Don't wanna crimp their lifestyle.
It may well spark controversy. Rachel talked to one of the Mn House members on radio last night. Mn Gov. has said over and over not to rush to judge, yet he (R) HAS rushed to refute ANY state actions from his admin as causal factors. It is so dirty all around. I hope that investigators and Mn citizens speak up.
I live in Minneapolis. There are a number of bridges around town that I cringe every time I go over them or under them. The roads up here are turning to shit. Many parts of I35 (East and West) are pot-holed to hell as are parts of 694. Since Jesse Ventura and now Tim Pawlenty have been in office, I have noticed a pronounced DECREASE in road repairs. The road issues up here are the direct result of 'no new taxes'. You get what you pay for.
I live less than a mile from where the bridge used to be. I'm not sure McCain and the other republicans appreciate just how unconservative The Cities are, and how attentive the polity is here. People will remember this idiot's words come September. Rush Limbaugh is hoping for convention riots? More talk like this and he may get his wish, with a twist. (That is a prediction, not advocacy.)
Login or Register to post comments.